Ray Dalio is one of the best economic thinkers alive. On 9 April 2020, TED interviewed him about what coronavirus means for the global economy. Here is my summary. Any errors, omissions, misunderstandings are mine.
Interviewer: Corey Hajim (TED)
Interviewee: Ray Dalio, Founder of Bridgewater Associates
Released 9 April 2020
How to think about this?
Look at second order effects – like a tsunami – what happens after the wave has gone? Look at incomes and balance sheets: big hits to both.
This is similar to the 1930-45 period, so read up on your history.
- Production of a lot credit-based money (govt borrowing). US Treasury is giving money to Americans. Europeans doing the same.
- Rest of world will have gaps/holes. Who will pay, who will fill these holes. Who will pay these debts?
- Will be a big difference between those who will get the money and who will not.
- Wealth distribution will be a big thing.
Will need to collaborate. This is a defining moment.
Think about the one pattern that happens over and over again – 4 driving forces of our economy (see https://www.economicprinciples.org):
- Productivity growth (learning, inventing, doing things well). Grows slowly. 1-3% per year. Not volatile. Raises living standards.
- Short term debt cycle (booms & busts), lasts about 8-10 years.
- Long term debt cycle, 50-75 years. New type of money & credit. Last one began in 1945 Bretton Woods. Start of American world order. USD powers 70% of the world. This is what’s going on now.
- Politics – how we deal with each other. Domestic and international politics.
Stress tests happen every 75 years (3rd force above). Think about those “inside the ring of (financial) support” vs “outside the ring of support”.
On politics, domestic politics is the wealth gap, the existence of the American dream etc. Revolutions do happen – whether this one will be peaceful or disruptive is the question. External politics is between countries – usually a rising power challenging existing power. There is a risk of war (12 of the last 16 challenges in the last 500 years have resulted in war). This time, will countries come together for the greater good or will they fight?
We’re headed into a global depression.
Meaning it will be like during 1929-1932 when there was double digit unemployment rate, 10% fall in the economy. Back then how did they deal with this? In 1933 they printed lots of money. Similar programs to now. Interest rates to 0. Same thing as today: credit/money expansion. Took a long time for stock market to exceed former highs & economy to recover to previous levels.
This is not a recession, it’s a breakdown in the operation of money & credit.
Tools previously used to fix it: Austerity, debt restructuring/forgiveness, redistribution of wealth, printing money? Can these help?
We’ll see printing money and redistribution. Need to leverage on human creativity and adaptation. We’ll get through this, this will be a tiny wiggle on the line, like how the others look when you zoom out.
There will be a new world order.
We see $20tn of losses. But money & credit is just digital, just accounting. We’ll see a giant restructuring of IOUs. Go entity by entity. Who will pay to keep them alive? Will take a couple of years to figure out the numbers. Who collects the cheques is important – who gets to survive. Then we’ll have a new working environment. This could make us healthier.
Supply chains will change – self sufficiency (nation by nation) will be important. Financial system will restructure.
This is bigger than what happened in 2008. Back then we were able to keep systemically important banks etc alive by extending them credit. This time it’s the real economy, those beyond banks. It’s a bigger crisis, and we have a less effective monetary policy (rates were lower going in). Simply buying financial assets won’t work this time. Need to get the money to those who need it.
Who has the best prospects going forwards? Two types:
- Those stable “meat & potato” unleveraged companies eg Campbell Soup.
- The Innovators / adaptors who have strong balance sheets.
How to understand it?
People lose sight of the basic fundamentals of money, credit, income, expenses, balance sheets, because shocks like this only happen once in anyone’s lifetime.
You need a firm grasp of cause-effect relationships. Don’t just apply machine learning to the markets, because we don’t have the training data for shocks like this. Your models won’t work. You’d have to go back to the 1930s to have analogous period.
Passive investment market is so huge now, what’s the impact?
Individual investors should know how to diversify well and in a balanced way (asset classes, countries, currencies). The greatest mistake of all investors is to think that what has done well lately is a better investment, rather than it’s expensive. And what has done badly recently is a worst investment, rather than it’s cheap.
Don’t think that cash is a safe investment. Cash is seductive but it taxes you in buying power (2% a year). Cash is often the worst investment. Think unconventionally – do you have a little bit of gold? (Note: he didn’t mention crypto or bitcoin… but those who know…).
Big picture question – what’s changing? There is a retreat from globalisation. We need a coordinated effort for recovery. (See Ray’s view on The Changing World Order)
We certainly will retreat from globalisation. Who will write what cheques in countries outside of their domain? Gets down to practical questions. The reality is a lot of people won’t be helped. One country’s vulnerabilities is another country’s opportunity. How to resolve dispute of who gets what? We’re in an interconnected but fragmented world. Can I depend on someone else giving me what I need, or not taking advantage of me? Not any more.
This separation / isolation of US vs rest-of-world began before we had Covid. Read the history. The Chinese right now are helping with things that are needed in this crisis. But even saying that is a politically challenging. Our world is so fragmented, it’s hard to say thank you to countries and companies that are helping. Right now there is demonisation of different people. How we come out of this depends on how we behave with each other.
Is this an opportunity to reform capitalism?
Do we want the outcomes that we’re getting, that the system is producing? The current world order was created at Bretton Woods in 1945. Environment of equal opportunity, American Dream, harmony, etc. You saw collapse, clash, fighting, followed by new systems.
The idea that the profit system can accomplish everything is not right: Resources are allocated to those who already have resources. All systems work for those who control the system – it’s self perpetuating. Eg in the US, the top 40% spend on average 5x on children’s education than those in the bottom 60%.
I’m a capitalist, I believe we can increase the size of the pie and divide it well. But needs reform and restructuring, that’s what’s happening now.
There has been a tremendous transfer of wealth through the production of borrowed money. We will come out of here, and over the next couple of years we will talk about how we do the restricting. My main worry: will this be done in a civil bipartisan way to increase the size of the pie and divide it well, or damage the economy by losing productivity?
Education is a great investment, the more well educated people the more productivity it will produce. But states and localities consider it as a budget item – an expense. That’s not the right way to think about education. This has to be engineered well. System has to be perceived to be fair.
I’m 60/40 pessimistic that we are not going to be good enough to do it well.
Is it genuinely possible to rebuild the economy to be fairer? Is the current crisis showing that it’s actually low pay / unskilled workers that holds countries together rather than bankers etc? Can we make the new system more fair for them?
They are definitely the heroes. But it takes everyone to buy in, both the CEOs and the workers on the front lines. We have to establish that there is a level of basics (education, healthcare, basics) that you can’t fall below, otherwise there’s no opportunity, and the cost is crime and incarcerations.
Our job is to get kids through high schools and in jobs: we will save money. Average cost of incarceration is $40-120k per year. The difference between a rich and poor student is whose who can have a computer and learn. Get them in jobs and we save a lot of money. Philanthropists can’t do this alone: the sums are too high.
On powerful people’s decision making:
You have to realise that very few people are making decisions based on the quality of the argument. Most people have an objective or are in a war of some kind, and they’re on one side. So they’re making decisions based on the side they’re taking rather than on high quality arguments. Everything is politically challenging – number of respirators etc. People on the other sides will take advantage.
We’re going to get through it. We have the opportunity to make changes, do better, and emerge stronger. We can improve the structures, but needs active cooperation. This is a defining moment.
Other Ray Dalio short videos:
U.S. Treasury Targets Stablecoins in Latest Regulatory Risk Assessment
As regulatory pressure mounts in the U.S., policymakers are putting stablecoins at the top of their agendas.
Citing “people familiar with the matter,” Bloomberg has reported that officials are crafting a policy framework set to be released in the coming weeks. Their primary concern is ensuring that investors can reliably move money in and out of tokens, it added.
The anonymous insiders are worried that a “fire-sale run on crypto assets could threaten financial stability and that certain stablecoins could scale up dangerously fast.”
Strengthening Regulatory Efforts
The Financial Stability Oversight Council is also preparing a formal review into whether stablecoins pose an economic threat.
The officials are focusing on how stablecoin transactions are processed and settled and whether market conditions have an impact, it added. Tomicah Tillemann, global head of policy at a crypto fund run by venture capital giant Andreessen Horowitz, commented:
“It is significant and very consequential that we are witnessing early steps to create a regulatory framework around digital assets. That’s a big deal.”
The report, when released, will go to the President’s Working Group on Financial Markets. The body includes key agency heads such as Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen, Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell, and Securities and Exchange Commissioner Chair Gary Gensler.
In late July, Yellen called for urgency in regulating stablecoins after stating that they are not adequately supervised. Gary Gensler echoed the sentiment in early August, stating that regulators must act to protect investors from fraud.
Also, in late July, Acting Comptroller of the Currency, Michael Hsu, said regulators are looking into Tether’s commercial papers to see whether each USDT token was really backed by the equivalent of one U.S. dollar.
Tether has repeatedly issued assurances that its reserves are fully backed but has yet to produce a full independent audit.
Stablecoin Ecosystem Update
Tether remains the market leader with a current supply of 69.4 billion, according to the Tether Transparency report. This is close to the all-time high for USDT, which tapped 70 billion earlier this week.
Of that total, 36 billion or 51.8% is based on the Tron network, with 33.8 billion or 48.7% running on Ethereum. USDT supply has grown by 232% since the beginning of the year.
Rival stablecoin, USDC, from Circle currently has 29.3 billion in circulation after gaining 651% in terms of supply growth so far in 2021.
PlatoAi. Web3 Reimagined. Data Intelligence Amplified.
Cardano, Chainlink, MATIC Price Analysis: 19 September
Most altcoins in the market have been consolidating or recording losses over the last 24 hours. Cardano fell by 3% and inched closer to the support line of $2.20. Chainlink also depreciated by 5% and was trading closer to its three-week low price. Lastly, MATIC was seen moving closer to its one-week low price of $1.29 after registering a loss of 5% over the past day.
Cardano lost 3% of its valuation over the last 24 hours. The altcoin was priced at $2.33. Over the last few days, ADA has been consolidating. The nearest support line for the coin stood at $2.20 and then at $1.72.
On the four-hour 20-SMA the alt’s price was seen below it, indicating that the momentum belonged to the sellers. The Relative Strength Index was below the 50-mark. The Chaikin Money Flow also was seen below the half-line as capital inflows were low.
MACD witnessed a bearish crossover and flashed red bars on its histogram. If ADA moved on the upside, the first resistance mark stood at $2.49, toppling which it could retest $2.79. The other price ceiling stood at the multi-month high of $3.04.
Chainlink was priced at $27.80 after it recorded a loss of 5% over the last 24 hours. LINK’s nearest price floor was at $27.78. Falling below which the coin could trade near its three-week low of $24.45.
Parameters pointed towards negative price action. On the four-hour chart, LINK’s price was below the 20-SMA. This reading suggested price momentum was inclined towards the sellers. The Relative Strength Index was below the half-line.
Awesome Oscillator flashed red signal bars. MACD also displayed red bars on its histogram. On the flipside, once buying pressure revives, the altcoin could attempt to retest the $32.37 resistance mark and then revisit $35.83.
MATIC depreciated by 5% and was trading at $1.39. The altcoin’s immediate support line was at $1.29 which also is the one-week low price level. The other price floor was at its over a month-long low price point of $1.07.
Bollinger Bands converged, indicating that price volatility would remain low over the upcoming trading sessions. MACD was bearish with red bars on its histogram. The Relative Strength Index was also seen below the half-line.
MATIC’s movement on the upside could mean that the coin would meet with its first resistance at $1.42 and then at $1.54. Toppling over these levels, the coin could revisit its multi-month high of $1.76.
Where to Invest?
Subscribe to our newsletter
PlatoAi. Web3 Reimagined. Data Intelligence Amplified.
The Crypto Mining Fight in China Is Not Over
It looks like China is still not done clamping down on the crypto mining space. Another region known as the Hebei province has agreed to comply with Beijing’s ruling that all crypto mining should be omitted from China’s workforce. The province is now claiming that the practice is illegal and must end within its borders no later than September 30.
China Is Still Kicking Miners Out
China shocked the world not too long ago when it decided that all crypto mining should cease. The idea was that energy used for crypto mining purposes was hazardous to the planet, and that it was setting humans on the wrong path. Thus, regulators stated that it was time to bring things to an official end.
What was most surprising about the ruling is that the country, at the time, was home to nearly 75 percent of the world’s total crypto mining operations. Thus, it stood to lose a lot of money and tax revenue by initiating the clampdown. In addition, the country is home to two of the world’s biggest developers and distributors of bitcoin mining equipment in Bitmain and Canaan Creative.
Nevertheless, China has moved forward in its decision. Many mining operators were forced to shut down their businesses and move elsewhere, and quite a few have popped up in countries such as Kazakhstan and in states like Texas and Florida. Both these regions in America have stated they are open to crypto mining projects given that they can potentially lead to healthier local and state economies, and they will create jobs for interested workers.
The Hebei province issued the following statement:
Cryptocurrency mining consumes an enormous amount of energy, which is against China’s ‘carbon neutral’ goal.
The arguments against crypto mining have become rather prominent in recent months. One of the most notable stemmed from Elon Musk, the South African entrepreneur behind billion-dollar companies such as SpaceX and Tesla. He stated early in the year that he was willing to permit bitcoin payments for electric vehicles. A few weeks later, however, he rescinded this decision, claiming that miners were not utilizing their energy correctly, and he could not condone bitcoin unless carbon emissions were brought down.
Too Much Bad Energy in the Air!
Another argument came from Kevin O’Leary of “Shark Tank” fame. The billionaire investor claimed that he would no longer be purchasing any BTC mined in China given that the country was not known to utilize green energy for mining purposes. China later took this issue to heart, it seems.
Starting in October of this year, bitcoin and crypto mining in China will be completely illegal. Regulators in the nation have stated that they will keep a close eye on the mining space and will work to punish all those who disobey the rules.
Click here for Free Trial.
Wicked Craniums are now Nifty Gateway!
Massive NFT and Token Giveaway from Polker as Staking is Announced!
Swissquote Confirms European Expansion Plan, Focusing on Crypto
Acorns Hires Former Amazon Executive as President, Hints at Crypto Options
Biggest Crypto Adoption Rumours: Apple, Amazon, and Walmart
Gate.io Introduces OpenPunks, A Community-Based NFT Collection
Investor: Coinbase’s $2 billion junk bond deal shows crypto ‘supercycle’ is in place
Head of Australian Crypto Exchange Says Regulations Are Beneficial
The Signal and the Noise
How to fix the Party Member Preloading error in Apex Legends
Evaluating Credit Card Debt Relief Options
Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl will include DLC fighters post-launch
Bingbon Launches its Carbon Free and Afforestation Project
Gods Unchained and Guild of Guardians Layer 2 Solution Immutable Raises $60 Million
Public.com Inks Deal with NFL Star to Advise on Financial Literacy Programs
Over 40 days after Ethereum’s EIP-1559, here’s where it stands
What’s Behind Elrond (EGLD) Daily Surges?
This needs to happen before Peter Schiff will buy Bitcoin (BTC)
Ethereum’s Infura Launches Tool To Prevent Over-payment Of Fees
xtingles To Drop Its First ASMR NFT “Free Like A Butterfly” On September 16
Uncategorized1 week ago
NBA 2K22 Error Code 4b538e50: What is it?
Uncategorized1 week ago
How to watch the Wild Rift Japan Cup 2021: Teams, format, and more
Uncategorized1 week ago
How to fix NBA 2K21, 2K22 error code 4b538e50
Uncategorized1 week ago
How to scan your face in NBA 2K22
Blockchain1 week ago
SBI-acquired TaoTao exchange in Japan relists XRP
News1 week ago
Axie Infinity Unveils September 2021 Updates
News1 week ago
PUBG Mobile becomes the most earning game in August 2021
Uncategorized7 days ago
Fortnite says goodbye to season 7 with an alien ship, explosions, and a cliffhanger